Frequently Asked Questions

🥜 Product & Ingredients

What ingredients are in Nutfection peanut butter?

We keep it simple and clean.

Every jar starts with organic peanut butter, then we add a small number of carefully selected ingredients depending on the flavor, like organic maple sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, cacao, or pumpkin spices.

Do you add sugar or sweeteners?

We use a small amount of organic maple sugar in most flavours, a natural sweetener with a lower glycemic index than refined sugar.

We never use artificial sweeteners, high-fructose corn syrup, or refined white sugar. The Chocolate Chip Dream flavour contains cane sugar as part of the fair trade chocolate chips. Every gram of added sugar is listed clearly on the nutrition label.

Does it contain palm oil or any added oils?

No. Never. Palm oil is one of the most common additives in commercial peanut butter, it's cheap, it prevents oil separation, and it extends shelf life.

We don't use it.

Our peanut butter is made with organic peanuts only, which means the oil you see at the top of the jar is natural peanut oil.

Are there any preservatives or additives?

None. Every Nutfection product is made with organic, recognisable ingredients only. No preservatives, no emulsifiers, no stabilisers, no artificial colours or flavours.

If you can't picture the ingredient growing in the ground or on a tree, it's not in our jar.

🏋️ Nutrition & Health

Is Nutfection peanut butter vegan?

Most of our flavors are 100% plant-based.

Only Chocolate Chip Dream contains milk (from chocolate chips). All other flavors are vegan-friendly.

Is it gluten-free?

Yes, all Nutfection peanut butters are naturally gluten-free.

Does it contain any allergens besides peanuts?

Peanuts are the main allergen.

Chocolate Chip Dream also contains milk due to the chocolate chips.

Is it suitable for a keto or low-carb diet?

Yes, with some nuance. All our flavours are relatively low in carbohydrates, between 9g and 11g of total carbs per 31g serving.

The Original flavour has the lowest added sugar content at 3g per serving, making it the most keto-compatible option.

The Chocolate Chip Dream has slightly higher carbs due to the chocolate chips. As always, factor your serving size into your daily macros.

🚚 Shipping & Delivery

Where do you ship?

We currently ship across the United States from our headquarters in Scottsdale, Arizona.

How long does delivery take?

Most orders are processed within 1–2 business days and arrive within 3–7 business days depending on your location.

We ship from Scottsdale, Arizona, so customers in the Southwest typically receive their order on the faster end of that window.

Do you offer free shipping?

Yes, free shipping on all orders over $55. If your order is just below the threshold, adding one more jar usually gets you there.

Can I track my order?

Yes, you’ll receive a tracking link by email as soon as your order ships.

What if my order arrives damaged?

We're sorry to hear that, it happens occasionally in transit and we'll always make it right.

Take a photo of the damaged item and packaging and email it to ryan@nutfection.com. We'll send a replacement or issue a full refund, your choice, no questions asked.

Can I cancel or modify my order?

We process orders quickly, so please contact us as soon as possible at ryan@nutfection.com if you need to make a change.

We'll do everything we can to accommodate you before the order ships. Once it's been dispatched, we're unable to modify it but our returns policy still applies.

📦 Storage & Usage

How should I store Nutfection peanut butter?

Store it in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight.

How long does it last after opening?

For best quality, we recommend enjoying it within 4 months after opening.

What happens if I store it in the fridge?

Refrigeration will make the texture thicker and firmer.

If you prefer a softer, spreadable texture, keep it at room temperature.

Is it safe to eat after the best-before date?

Yes, in most cases, as long as it looks and smells normal.

The best-before date is about quality, not safety.

How do I know if my peanut butter has gone bad?

If you notice an unusual smell, taste, or appearance, it’s best not to consume it.

💳 Orders & Payments

What payment methods do you accept?

We accept all major credit and debit cards, Visa, Mastercard, American Express, as well as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Shop Pay. All transactions are processed securely through Shopify's encrypted checkout.

Is it safe to order from Nutfection?

Yes. Our store runs on Shopify, one of the most trusted e-commerce platforms in the world. Your payment information is encrypted and never stored on our servers.

We take your security seriously and will never share your data with third parties for marketing purposes.

How do I know if my order was successful?

You'll receive an order confirmation email within a few minutes of placing your order.

If you don't see it, check your spam or promotions folder.

If it's not there either, contact us at ryan@nutfection.com and we'll confirm your order status right away.

🌱 Brand Values & Sourcing

Where do your peanuts come from?

Our peanuts are organically grown and sourced from trusted suppliers who meet our quality standards. We use dry roasted peanuts, not oil roasted, which means no extra fats are added during the roasting process.

We're committed to sourcing transparently and will always share more detail as our supply chain grows.

Are your peanuts organic?

Yes. All our products are made with certified organic peanut butter as the base. You'll see "organic peanut butter" as the first ingredient on every label. Organic certification means no synthetic pesticides, herbicides, or GMOs in the growing process.

How do you ensure the quality of your ingredients?

Every ingredient in a Nutfection jar is individually selected for quality, organic where possible, fair trade where applicable, and always non-GMO.

We make our products in small batches, which means we have direct visibility and control over every step of the process. If an ingredient doesn't meet our standard, it doesn't go in the jar.

What makes Nutfection different from other peanut butter brands?

Most peanut butters make you choose. The clean ones taste like cardboard. The ones that taste good are full of palm oil, added sugar, and ingredients you can't pronounce.

Nutfection was built to close that gap, organic ingredients, real flavour, nothing hidden.

We're a small-batch operation run by someone who started this because he genuinely couldn't find a peanut butter he trusted. That's still the standard every jar is held to.

Shop Our Premium Peanut Butters